Apparently, his corn cob pipe is being replaced by a whistle this time around (and just like Genndy's version, most aren't pleased)
Genndy Tartakovsky's animation test was fantastic regardless of the pipe missing. It had so much affection and love for the Fleischer cartoons, as well as some of the most impressively cartoony CG animation I've seen. I'd have gladly gone to see an animated Popeye feature directed by Genndy whether the pipe was there or not.
But if you simply aren't allowed to use the pipe, I'm honestly not sure what the best solution is... remove it altogether, or replace it with something as gimmicky and silly as this whistle apparently is.
These YouTube cartoons signal to me that King Features has given up on Sony ever actually making their theatrical Popeye feature (or at least, realizing it's very far off at this point)... so now, they're rebooting him themselves. I'm a little sad they aren't just letting Popeye keep his pipe, because on YouTube they don't have to deal with television's Broadcast Standards and Practices. But I guess they're still afraid of getting complaints and backlash about it.
Edited by user
2018-12-01T21:20:55Z
|
Reason: Typo