Mac
  • Mac
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
2015-04-24T15:14:25Z
Has anyone else here been reading the Fantagraphics reprints of Floyd Gottfredson’s Mickey Mouse comic strips?
I absolutely love this series and have just finished reading the latest two books ‘Outwits the Phantom Blot’ and ‘Lost in Lands of Long Ago’, so I thought I’d share a few odd thoughts about them and hope some others here want to join in the discussion.

Reading the strips in chronological order (along with many I’d never read before) has offered me lots of surprises. One of the best of them is the continuity between the strips. I used to think that each story was its own separate entity, but since the first volume of the reprints, I was surprised how one story flows into the next and I’m pleased that this trend is lasting into the latest volumes (which take us up to 1942). In the animated cartoons each short is its own separate thing – Mickey’s adventures can take place in any time in history and no matter how often Mickey battles with Pete it could often be the for the first time (fans often explain this as the characters being actors playing roles). Not so in the strip! Mickey has a contemporary home to return to and characters remember each other and what they did. Mickey and Pete remember their previous run-ins, Mickey can build a reputation for himself and win favour with characters like Chief O’ Hara and if Clarabelle gets kidnapped in one story, Goofy can throw a ‘welcome back’ party for her in the next! I find the the continuity so entertaining, it’s actually disappointing when there is the odd lapse, such as some occasional character inconsistencies or a sudden leap in logic (like Walt Disney giving Mickey a call because he actually is an actor in cartoons!).

Another big surprise for me was the Phantom Blot. I remember when I was about 8 or 9 digging out a reprint of this story in some ‘Disney Mirror’ newspaper comics destined to be recycled. The Blot was a Disney character I already kind of knew (though I don’t remember from where), but it was my first opportunity to read a story in which he was featured. I was excited to finally find out more about this character and read such a cool story. However, I never got hold of the comic containing the ending. Reading the complete story, over 20 years later, I was astonished to find that the Blot was unmasked (and in his very first story)! All this time I thought the Phantom Blot was forever a figure cloaked in mystery!

There’s a lot more I could say about these volumes, but I think I’ll wait and see if anyone elsewants to chat about them too! I will say though, that it’s brilliant all these comics are being so lovingly ordered and presented in one collection. It means that the Floyd Gottfredson strips can be found and researched so much more easily and I really hope it will introduce more people to the more adventure-orientated Mickey and hopefully inspire more Disney artists. I’m waiting for someone at Disney to realise that they have all the characters in place for an absolutely incredible adventure-based video game franchise.
nickramer
2015-04-26T02:42:50Z
I got all the volumes, so far. They are very enjoyable as well the duck collections by Fantagraphics. I'm also happy that after a four-year hiatus, monthly Disney comics are being published in U.S. again. This time, they are being published by IDW with David Gerstein as editor of the line.
Mac
  • Mac
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
2015-04-27T08:04:56Z
Yeah, I've been collecting and enjoying the Carl Bark and Don Rosa series too. I read a little about the new US Disney comics (I'm in the UK and I'm not even sure if Disney comics have been published here since the 90s). To be honest I'm happier collecting the hard cover books of artists that I'm already a big fan of (don't think my shelves could take it if I started regularly collecting new comics), but with David Gerstein as editor, you know it's gonna be a quality product. Between Rosa, Bark and Gottfredson, Fantagraphics have been releasing the Disney comics I'm most interested, however I'm such a big fan of 30s Disney, I wouldn't mind collecting the early Donald and Silly Symphony strips which then probably make me want to read a complete collection of Al Taliafero.
Blob55
2015-04-27T18:22:04Z
Originally Posted by: Mac 

however I'm such a big fan of 30s Disney, I wouldn't mind collecting the early Donald and Silly Symphony strips which then probably make me want to read a complete collection of Al Taliafero.



Yeah, I really want to see the SS and early Donald Duck comics too.

The next book comes out in June, but I'm not sure if I should wait until Vol. 8 is out or not.
FleischerFan
2015-05-04T23:09:10Z
I have been enjoying the Mickey volumes tremendously. But I have to admit that after "The Blot" story, my enthusiasm for the strip tapers off. I really like Mickey much better during the "shoe-button eye" era. I'm thinking that Volume 6 will be my last.

Originally Posted by: Mac 

...I'm such a big fan of 30s Disney, I wouldn't mind collecting the...Silly Symphony strips...



I would love to see these as well as the later Treasury of Classics Tales strips that replaced Silly Symphonies. I have been trying to compile a list of all the various continuities that ran under those two titles, from the first Bucky Bug in 1934 to the last Tramp's Cat-astrophe in 1987, but I have a lot of gaps.

Does anybody have or know where I could find a complete listing of those strips?
Mac
  • Mac
  • Advanced Member Topic Starter
2015-05-05T09:35:35Z
That's a pity that your enthusiasm has waived after "The Blot". I've still thoroughly enjoyed the stories so stories so far, with the latest story in the books., "The Gleam" containing some of the biggest laughs. I've been learning my Gottfredson history by reading these books and, when I started, I wondered how I'd react and if I'd get to a point where I lost my own enthusiasm. Luckily it hasn't happened yet.

Early on, I thought I might be sorry to see the more playful, mischievous Mickey grow into a more sensible hero, but it turned out he remains a lot of fun and the change made possible some great stories. (though it is a shame what happened to Minnie who has lost a lot of her humour now these books have got to the 40s). Character design-wise I'll always love that "shoe-button eye" Mickey too, but the drawings continue to be slick and impressive with Mickey's design changing slightly from story to story.

I wonder how I'll react as Mickey's design changes to "big-ugly snout" Mickey (which has already started to sneak in). Also the books haven't yet reached a story with Eega Beeva. I haven't read any of them since I was a kid, but I remember I absolutely hated that character...

Getting back to "The Blot", did anyone else think that the main Mickey pic used on the cover was an odd choice? The design on these books is fantastic, but I thought it was weird to use a non-Floyd Gottfredson pic as the main image on a book of his work, especially when the Blot story itself has loads of great Mickey drawings.
Users browsing this topic