Hi all,
I pulled out my Marx Brothers movie collection this weekend, when I noticed the animation done during the opening credits to two of their films. "Horse Feathers" from 1932 has the briefest of animated sequences--it lasts about 3 seconds, where an animated horse gallops towards the screen. "Room Service" from 1938 doesn't have much more--animated caricatures of the Marx Brothers appear above a wall, then they each open and close a door. Altogether, maybe 5 seconds of animation.
Does anybody know who animated these sequences? "Horse Feathers" was made by Paramount, so it would be natural for Fleischer to have done it. However, the animation doesn't look particularly Fleischer-esque, and given that the sequence is so short and the film was made in Hollywood while Fleischer Studios were in New York, perhaps another studio was contracted?
Same goes for "Room Service". It's an RKO picture, and the animation looks like it could possibly be Disney, but it seems that Disney would have bigger fish to fry.
Does anybody have any background on these?
Also, can you think of any other films from the 1930s or before with animation in the credits? This page has a bunch of examples, but the earliest are The Lady Eve (1941) and Abbott & Costello Meet Frankenstein (1948):
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/AnimatedCreditsOpeningJust curious--are these two Marx Brothers films the earliest live action feature films with animation in the credits?
Thanks!